The Discart-Bonetti
Chess Match, 1863
Page 1
2
3
4
5
Cornelius
Bonetti: The Snake
The birth date of Cornelio Bonetti is not known,
but this strong Italian player died in Rome, circa 1875. He was an Engineer, a
designer of railways and tunnels, and was considered among the strongest
Modenese players in the mid-19th century. Bonetti was one of Discart's favorite
opponents, with whom he played several matches, coming out inferior by only a
small margin. In 1849 he played against Calvi, and obtained an even score (+8
=4 -8). In Modena chess circles he was nicknamed "il Biscione" (the Snake) for
his sudden and unexpected attacks on the chessboard. When already an old man he
faced Dubois, but lost the encounter. Bonetti composed various problems,
published mainly in the Rivista degli Scacchi of 1859, but also in the
Schachzeitung of 1847, 1848, and 1862. See the Dizionario Enciclopedico degli
Scacchi, p. 59.
The
following two games, found among Discart's papers, are fine examples of
Bonetti's sharp and aggressive style.
Click below to see Bonetti's chess games:
Snake.htm
Note: the
Dizionario Enciclopedico and other trustworthy sources, including the Storia degli Scacchi in Italia, report Bonetti's first name as "Carlo". However,
since Discart's handwritten papers unequivocally speak of "Cornelio"
Bonetti, we have to assume that Discart, being a primary source, is more
accurate. Therefore "Carlo" is probably a mistake traceable to the
fact that 19th century chess publications reported his name as merely "C.
Bonetti".
The Discart – Bonetti Match 1863
As mentioned previously, this match was a clear
victory for Discart. At the very start, however, we find an unexpected win by
Bonetti in the opening game, in which Discart had secured a clearly superior
position, or nearly winning, but ruined it with a serious mistake in the
middlegame. After a draw in the second game, Discart took the upper hand with 3
smooth and easy wins in the 3rd, 4th and 5th games. Bonetti's reaction
consisted of two hard-fought wins in the 6th and 7th games, encounters
featuring Discart again throwing away good chances owing to inaccuracies. But
this rally was Bonetti's last, for in the remaining 8 games Discart scored a
total of 6 wins and a draw, losing only one game.
A few notes about the openings played in this
match. Excepting the 2nd game, in which Bonetti played 1.f4, all the games of
the match started with the King's Pawn opening, 1.e4, with 1.e4 e5 played in 10
out of the 15 games – in good 19th century fashion. Discart's main weapon was
the Evans Gambit, of which he was a great connoisseur, while Bonetti often
aimed for the Giuoco Piano. One is surprised to see Bonetti defend himself,
playing Black, with 1.e4 e5 2.Nf3 Nf6 3.Bc4 Bd6 in the 13th game, and with 1.e4
e5 2.Nf3 Bd6 in the 15th and final game. We might also remark Bonetti's 1.f4 d5
2.c4 in the 2nd game, but these movements are likely due to the
anti-theoretical approach of Bonetti himself who, as recorded, was not very
well versed in opening theory even of the 19th century, and who probably aimed
only at reaching a playable middlegame position. Discart, the theoretician, was
instead very quick at exploiting inaccuracies in the opening, as seen clearly
in the 3rd and 9th games.
The Discart
– Bonetti Match
Modena (January 7-24) 1863
Discart, F.
0
= 1 1
1 0 0
1 1 1
1 0 =
1 1
10
Bonetti, C.
1
= 0 0
0 1 1
0 0 0
0 1 = 0
0
5
Games of a Match Between Discart and Bonetti
played
In January of the Year 1863
Here are
given all 15 games of the Discart-Bonetti match, Modena 1863. To reach a wider audience of
international readers, the original 19th century Italian language has been
translated into modern English, and the old descriptive Italian chess notation
converted into modern algebraic notation. While viewing these games recall
again the three special rules described earlier, and observe that
"free" castling is represented as two (or three) consecutive moves by
the same player. In actual play castling is simply one action, as we know it,
and so the move numbers in the Notation Window are distorted after one side
castles "free" – a concession to the machine age. Click the HTML
below to see the match; all game annotations are by Francesco Discart.
Great Match
At the Game of Chess
Match between Engineer Cornelio
Bonetti
And Cavalier Francesco Discart both of Modena
Played in Modena at the home of Count Ferdinando
Cassoli
In
the Month of January of the Year 1863
match.htm
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
The Discart-Bonetti Match, 1863
Copyright (C) 2004 by Alessandro Nizzola
All comments, suggestions, improvements,
corrections, tips, advice, and general trivia are welcome. These may be
directed to the publisher:
Pickard & Son, Publishers
P.O. Box 2320
Wylie, TX 75098
tel:
972-429-9052 fax: 972-429-9053
e-mail:
mailto:chess@ChessCentral.com
Page 1
2
3
4
5
|